Paying Attention to Cancer Pays Off for Your Employees
Lillie Shockney is a University Distinguished Service Professor of Breast Cancer and a professor of surgery and oncology, at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine. She is the co-developer of the Work Stride: Managing Cancer at Work program.
Here’s the good news about cancer, according to 2017 statistics from the American Cancer Society: nearly 15.5 million people diagnosed with cancer are surviving their illness, and about 53 percent of them are under the age of 70. As an employer, that means you will likely be paying the cancer-related health care costs for many more years than employers in the past, when the employee population tended to retire at age 62 or 65 rather than 67 or 70, or beyond.
Employers need to pay attention to these costs.
Consider this: for every 100 employees in the workforce, 5 percent will have a history of cancer and 27.1 percent of employees will be in treatment for cancer. A 2015 initiative of the Northeast Business Group on Health (NEBGH) notes that “employers report a level of complexity in managing employees’ cancer-related needs beyond that associated with any other type of disease or condition” due, in large part, to the related costs. Cancer treatment alone accounts for 12 percent of employers’ total medical costs in the United States, with $125 billion spent on direct medical costs.
And keep in mind that another $139 billion are associated with diminished productivity and lost work time, either for cancer treatment or for caring for someone with cancer. Employees who are also caregivers account for nearly 75 percent of early departures and late arrivals at the workplace, often engaged in long telephone calls at work to handle caregiving issues. And caregivers often suffer stress-related illnesses, further reducing their productivity.
Employers need to pay attention to these employees.
The incidence of cancer is going up. As of 2017, 1 in 2 men and 1 in 3 women will be diagnosed with a life-threatening form of cancer in their lifetime. And although cancer deaths have risen to more than 600,000 annually, by 2024, it is expected there will be more than 20 million cancer survivors.
An overwhelming majority of employees who have received a cancer diagnosis—particularly those with breast cancer—either want to or need to keep working through treatment. Many people strongly identify with the work they do and the company they do it for. Among the roughly 40 percent of cancer survivors who are age 25 to 64, there’s often a feeling of loss of that identity as well a loss of a satisfaction with life and connectivity with friends who are work colleagues. These and other concerns can and do impact a cancer patient’s productivity and very ability to work.
And employers are generally best served by having their experienced employees remain on the job and be as productive as they possibly can for as long as they possibly can. Again, from the 2015 NEBGH report: “Employers are concerned that programs and services to assist employees through the cancer journey appear to be limited and/or uncoordinated…[they] are searching for the best way to engage employees beyond traditional health plan programs, because as one employer noted: “I know my employees won’t even pick up the phone if they see their health plan on their [c]aller ID.”
So, here’s the question: What can you do to support your employees, both before and after a cancer diagnosis, keep your company running efficiently, and manage the related health care costs?
The Johns Hopkins experience
We asked the same question at Johns Hopkins in February 2012. I and my colleague at the Sidney Kimmel Comprehensive Cancer Center at Johns Hopkins, Terry Langbaum, informed our leadership that while we were among the nation’s most highly regarded cancer centers for diagnosis and treatment, we were not doing a particularly good job of supporting our own employees who had cancer or who were providing care for a loved one with cancer and still wanted to work. And we identified a gap in supporting supervisors who needed to understand the often complex issues related to managing these employees. Their colleagues.
We began a 4-month initiative to better understand what sort of engagement would best support both employees and managers. Here’s what we learned from employees:
- We learned that most employees receiving cancer treatment are actually able to work throughout most of their treatments; this is because treatments have improved over the years and many have fewer side effects and, therefore, have less of an impact on a person’s quality of life. Employees didn’t always think to let managers know that for various reasons cancer treatment and how one feels after it may be better or worse than expected from one treatment to the next, so they might be able to work, or not, regardless of their plan;
- We learned that most employees are not fully aware of their company’s policy on sick leave, telecommuting, and flex time schedules;
- We learned that many employees do not know which websites and other resources provide credible information about risk factors, symptoms of specific cancers, and treatment options. So they end up wasting a lot of precious time trying to make sense of their condition and their options from often misinformed providers.
Here’s what we learned from managers:
- They (and co-workers) want to support a colleague when told he or she has been diagnosed with cancer, but not everyone has the ability—the skill, really—to provide that support. Supervisors and co-workers can be at a loss for words, or worse, say and do the entirely the wrong thing. They may not be fully versed on their employees’ rights. We learned that managers need immediate access to this information when they learn they have an employee dealing with cancer. And that information must be continuously updated to include changes to internal policies and state and federal laws;
- We learned that managers who provide reasonable work flexibility for their employees in treatment or caregiving are commonly able to keep their employees on the job. Keeping your employee team intact has a positive effect on morale and productivity, for both the employee with cancer and her/his co-workers, who are likely to be part of their support system;
- We learned that managers are not as familiar as they need to be with the American with Disabilities Act (ADA), so they don’t inadvertently (or intentionally) fail to accommodate an employee with cancer. There have been situations across the country where employees have won high-dollar law suits because a supervisor eliminated the employee’s job or even fired the employee for not performing up to par while undergoing cancer treatment. Lack of managerial training can be an expensive incident for the company to have to bear, not to mention the company’s reputation.
Work Stride: Managing Cancer at Work
With this information, we began to build an employee benefit program that addressed what we’d learned.
The program is now called Work Stride: Managing Cancer at Work. Collaborating with our health literacy and patient education colleagues, we developed a comprehensive web-based platform with resources for employees at risk, newly diagnosed, surviving after treatment, and serving as a caregiver to a loved one. Employers also can choose to provide their workforce with a specially trained Johns Hopkins certified oncology nurse navigator, who is a patient advocate and resource, providing employees and managers with 24/7 telephonic, email, text support.
There are two important philosophies ingrained in Work Stride: Managing Cancer at Work. The first is to enable an employee to work while receiving their cancer treatment, if they so choose. This approach is based on one of my long-held mantras: Only give cancer the time it needs to get rid of it. Don’t allow it to steal away any more of a your time, your family time, your social time, your personal time, or even your work time. It doesn’t deserve it. Working provides a sense of normalcy, and maintain normalcy during any crisis reduces stress.
The second philosophical grounding is this: Survivorship must begin at the time of diagnosis. This means keeping the patient’s life goals preserved rather than forfeited to this disease and its treatment. The Johns Hopkins nurse navigator gives priority to working with the patient as her/his advocate so that these life goals are known to the treatment team. The treatment team in turn can then incorporate these life goals into the treatment planning process.
So, how are we doing?
We identified a technology partner, which gave us the ability in October 2014 to pilot the web-based platform and oncology nurse navigator with Pitney Bowes’ 10,000 employees. In January 2015, we launched the program for the approximately 31,000 employees across The Johns Hopkins University and Health System. And we’ve received positive feedback from employees with cancer, those who are caring for someone with cancer, and managers:
- Employee’s satisfaction with the program on a scale of 1-5, 5 being excellent ranges from 4.5 to 4.8;
- 94 percent of employees who became cancer patients found the nurse navigator to be very helpful;
- Prior to communicating with the nurse navigator;
- 33 percent lacked information about their treatment plan;
- 50 percent didn’t really understand their insurance coverage;
- 37 percent lacked knowledge of support organizations and other available free resources;
- The most common sections of the website content visited has been
- Screening/ prevention/risk assessment tool;
- What if I am diagnosed;
- Working during treatment.
And as we hoped, the most frequent statement from managers and supervisors using the program—“I wish this program had been implemented sooner.”
This article was originally published in the September 2017 issue of The Self Insurer magazine.
Learn more about how Work Stride: Managing Cancer at Work can benefit your employees.